A 1937 Auction of Queen Alexandra’s Clothing (Part II)

Picking up from where Part I left off, this segment covers lots 31 to 70 of the 1937 auction of the clothing of Queen Alexandra of the United Kingdom (1844-1925). As before, I have highlighted items I have not been able to find in any collection, in yellow:

31. EMBROIDERED YELLOW SATIN AND HELIOTROPE STATE GOWN
Pale amber yellow satin embroidered with silver sequins and design of iris in appliqué silks painted heliotrope and pale green, outlined with crystal bugles; taffeta lining with chiffon flounce at hem. Bell-shaped separate skirt with train; pointed bodice with V-neck and tulle scarf sleeves. Worn during the Coronation year, 1902.

This veritable beauty of a gown is now part of the Royal Ontario Museum’s collection (figure 1.7):

32. SHELL PINK WOOL DRIVING COAT
Heavy shell pink woolen coat, trimmed with pink braid, the edges trimmed with lappets. Part of H. M. Queen Alexandra’s trousseau.

Queen Alexandra would have worn such a coat to keep her warm and snug while riding in her carriage; unfortunately, its current whereabouts are unknown.

33. EMBROIDERED GOLD TULLE STATE GOWN WITH TISSUE FLOWERS
In one piece, with train and scarf sleeves; of pale yellow tulle appliqué embroidered with gold tissue flowers, tissue bands under tulle, and gold sequins and bugles; pale yellow satin and chiffon foundations. Worn at Buckingham Palace in 1907, on the occasion of the State visit of royalty, during the Kaiser’s visit in November, 1907, on the King’s birthday; among the guests were the Princess Royal, Duke of  Connaught, Queen of Norway, the German Emperor, Prince of Wales, Princess of Wales, Princess Patricia, Princess Victoria, Prince Johann of Saxony, Prince Olaf, Grand Duchess Vladimir, and the Queen of Portugal.

33. Embroidered gold tulle state gown with tissue flowers [catalogue photo].

The dress now resides at the Met, as golden-looking and glorious as ever (figure 1.8):

34. ROYAL BLUE SEQUIN AND TULLE GOWN
Embroidered with blue sequins and bugles on navy blue tulle with floral design; blue chiffon and black taffeta underdress.  Separate skirt with train, and low-cut bodice overlapping in the front, with long scarf sleeves. Worn during the Coronation year; a favorite gown of Her Majesty’s, worn on many fashionable occasions, also for H. M. the King’s birthday.

Unfortunately, this is a gown that has yet to resurface since the 1937 auction.

35. BLACK AND GOLD SILK COAT
Black and gold silk woven in stripes with a plain gold panel in back; cut with high neck and bell sleeves; trimmed with gold frogs and claw buttons, and fringe. Yellow taffeta lining. Part of H. M. Queen Alexandra’s trousseau.

This is yet another of the coats from Queen Alexandra’s trousseau that awaits discovery.

36. EMBROIDERED WHITE SATIN STATE GOWN
Of white satin, back and front panels with appliqué borders of rose tissue covered with embroidered tulle bearing floral rinceaux in gold cordonnets and bugles. In one piece, with short rose tissue sleeves and square -cut neck. Worn by H. M. the Queen in Portugal (1904) on a visit to the King and Queen of Portugal; also worn for State visits and at the Grand Opera, Lisbon.

Yet another gown that is missing.

37. MAUVE SEQUIN AND TULLE GOWN
Of solid sequin embroidery with ribbon and bowknot motives in deeper mauve; chiffon and taffeta underskirts, with pleated flounces at hem; bodice with square-cut neck and puffed sleeves with lace flounce. Worn by H. M. the Queen during the Coronation year. 1902.

This sparkling princess-line gown in the Met’s online database corresponds with the description in the catalogue (see figure 1.9):

38. SILVER AND GOLD-EMBROIDERED BLACK TULLE STATE GOWN
Black tulle appliqué-embroidered with an allover design of curling silver floral branches, the blossoms heightened with gold; black satin foundation. Separate bell-form skirt with train, hem with tulle flounces; two printed bodices with puffed sleeves of tulle pique with sequins. Together with long detachable state train with similar embroidered border and tulle ruching. The gown and train were embroidered especially for H. M. Queen Alexandra by the wives of all the ruling princes of India, made up in Paris, and presented to her on her becoming Queen of England; worn for one of the Courts held after the Coronation, April 25, 1904. The Orders worn were the Order of the Garter, the Victoria and Albert, the Crown of India, St. John of Jerusalem, and the Danish Family Order.

38. Silver and gold-embroidered black tulle state gown [catalogue photo].

The Met’s photographs of the black four-piece court gown in lot 38 of the auction show it both with and without its detachable train, as well as the two bodices (see figure 1.10):

40. SILVER-EMBROIDERED WHITE SATIN STATE GOWN
Richly embroidered with silver sequins and bugles, paste, and metal thread, with bands of flowers; separate bell-form skirt with train, printed bodice with white tulle scarf sleeves and décolletage. Worn by H. M. Queen during the Court held at Dublin Castle, July, 1903.

Yet another beautiful gown, if the above description is anything to go by, but unfortunately one that has been lost to the general public since 1937.

41. ROSE-PINK VELVET ROBE
Cut with full skirt and train, and long cape; trimmed with silver buttons and narrow galloon of silver sequins. Worn by H. M. the Queen at the wedding of the Grand Duchess Xenia, daughter of Czar Alexander III, to H.R.H. the Duke of Edinburgh, at Peterhof Palace.

This is a rather puzzling entry, considering that her brother-in-law Alfred, Duke of Edinburgh (1844-1900), married Grand Duchess Maria Alexandrovna of Russia (1853-1920), daughter of Tsar Alexander II, in 1874, not Grand Duchess Xenia Alexandrovna (1875-1960), who was Queen Alexandra’s own niece and did not marry until 1894! Nonetheless, one can safely assume that Queen Alexandra wore the dress in question to the 1874 wedding (which did take place in Russia), based on the fact that she wore the gown in lot 16 to Xenia’s nuptials (see Part I).

Although the “rose-pink velvet robe” currently remains unaccounted for, one can imagine what it would have looked like, thanks to Nicholas Chevalier’s (1828-1902) detailed study of the dress (figure 1.11), as well as his painting of the 1874 wedding ceremony (see figure 1.12). In the handwritten notes accompanying the study, Chevalier draws the viewer’s attention to the silver brocade silk of the skirt and the rose velvet of the overskirt (which would have lengthened itself into a court train), embellished with silver-embroidered roses, shamrocks and thistles.

Figure 1.11. Nicholas Chevalier, A Study of the Dress Worn by the Princess of Wales for the Marriage of the Grand Duchess Maria to Alfred, Duke of Edinburgh, January 23, 1874, pencil, watercolour, bodycolour and silver paint with scraping out, 25 x 19 cm, Royal Collection Trust, RCIN 926235, source: RCT.
Figure 1.12. Detail showing Princess Alexandra of Wales (centre, flanked by Crown Princess Victoria of Prussia and Grand Duchess Maria Fyodorovna of Russia) at the Duke of Edinburgh’s wedding. Nicholas Chevalier, The Marriage of Prince Alfred, Duke of Edinburgh, 23 January 1874, 1874-75, oil on canvas, 168.4 x 138.5 cm, Royal Collection Trust, RCIN 404476, source: RCT.

42. SILVER-EMBROIDERED LIGHT GRAY WOOL CAPE
Of pale gray cloth with upstanding collar, with Turkish embroidery in silver; blue sateen lining. Part of H. M. Queen Alexandra’s trousseau.

Another item from Queen Alexandra’s trousseau that has not been seen since the 1937 sale.

43. GOLD AND SILVER EMBROIDERED WHITE TULLE STATE GOWN
White tulle embroidered in gold and silver sequins and bugles and with festoons of delicate opalescent gold flowers; fastening in front with a narrow plain panel of white chiffon; short sleeves, square-cut neck. With train. Worn at Buckingham Palace for State visits.

The whereabouts of this gown are also unknown.

44. BLACK CHIFFON AND BLUE AND SILVER SEQUIN GOWN
Of black chiffon overlaying light blue chiffon on a black satin foundation; embroidered in blue and silver sequins with a large shaded floral design. Separate bell-shaped skirt with train; two bodices, one with short sleeves trimmed with black lace, the other décolleté with short black tulle sleeves. Worn at Buckingham Palace and Windsor Castle.

This three-piece gown is missing as well.

45. DANISH WHITE WOOL AND LAMB DRIVING COAT
With wide borders and deep collar of white lamb; trimmed with gold braid and frogs, lined in light yellow taffeta. Part of H. M. Queen Alexandra’s trousseau.

Pictures of this driving coat, now part of the Met’s costume collection, can be seen in figure 1.13:

46. EMBROIDERED BLACK TULLE GOWN
With heavy chain-stitch and appliqué velvet embroidery in black; satin underskirt. In one piece, with train, square-cut bodice and puffed sleeves. Said to have been H. M. the Queen’s favorite dinner gown, worn at Christmas and Easter at Sandringham.

Lot 46 was the last of Queen Alexandra’s gowns on offer and like so many of the others in this auction, there has been no sign of it since it was sold.

54. CORAL SATIN AND LACE APRON
Composed of satin lappets with ruching and écru lace borders. Part of H. M. Queen Alexandra’s trousseau.

In November 2020, this so-called apron featured in an auction of Hollywood memorabilia. Even more unbelievably, the auctioneer, Profiles in History, referred to the item as a collar and even presented it as such on a mannequin (see figure 1.14). Nevertheless, the lot description provides a fuller picture of the object’s provenance by supplying the inscription on the internal bias label: “1902 P-A-I. Worn by H. M. Queen Alexandra. Part of her trousseau. Purchased through Samuel Wilson Soden – May 5 – 1937 Traphagen School.”1 In all likelihood, an inventory of Queen Alexandra’s former wardrobe as Princess of Wales was carried out in 1902, the year of her coronation, and so it is plausible that “P-A-I” stands for “Princess Alexandra Inventory.” New York’s Traphagen School of Fashion, which existed between 1923 and 1991 and trained well-known American designers,2 bought the “collar” at the 1937 auction, as indicated by the garment’s label, and most likely added it to its study collection.

Costume historian Kate Strasdin has pointed out that the garment, which is now in a private collection, is not a collar, cape or apron, but rather a peplum that would have been worn over an 1860s skirt.3

Figure 1.14. Profiles in History, “The Icons and Legends of Hollywood (Day 1): November 13, 2020,” lot 1, source: LiveAuctioneers.

It is disappointing that even now, decades later, with fashion researchers, historians and collectors on the hunt for Queen Alexandra’s clothing, so many pieces from the 1937 sale have yet to turn up. Feel free to write back if you know where any of them may be located.

Notes

1. “Queen Alexandra of Denmark Satin and Lace Collar. – Nov 12, 2020 | Profiles in History in CA,” LiveAuctioneers, accessed January 10, 2024, https://www.liveauctioneers.com/item/91727606_queen-alexandra-of-denmark-satin-and-lace-collar.

2. “The Traphagen School: Fostering American Fashion | Fashion Institute of Technology,” The Museum at FIT, accessed January 10, 2024, https://www.fitnyc.edu/museum/exhibitions/traphagen-school.php.

3. Kate Strasdin, December 28, 2023, comment on Faiza Mahmud, “A 1937 Auction of Queen Alexandra’s Clothing (Part I),” Lost and Found (blog), January 29, 2022, https://dressingroyalty.wordpress.com/2022/01/29/a-1937-auction-of-queen-alexandras-clothing-part-i/; Dr Kate Strasdin (@kateStrasdin), “This is a curiosity. Selling at auction @pihauctions next month & belonging to Alexandra, #PrincessofWales, it was originally sold at a famous auction,” Twitter, October 29, 2020, 2:29 p.m., https://twitter.com/kateStrasdin/status/1321745851459522560. Pointing out that the word “peplum” first came into use in 1866, the Oxford English Dictionary defines it as, “The part of a woman’s jacket or tunic which hangs below the waist; a jacket or tunic having such a design,” before going on to describe it as “†a kind of overskirt resembling the ancient peplos (obsolete).” This latter, now defunct, definition seems to apply in this context.

Bibliography

American Art Association-Anderson Galleries, Inc. Royal Robes and State Gowns, Including Toilettes Worn at the Coronation and from the Trousseau of H. M. Queen Alexandra, Comprising Coats, Kashmir Shawls, Bags, Gloves and Embroidered Slippers, with Other Examples of the Richest Fashions of the Period from 1863 to 1907: Auction in New York, May 5, 1937. New York: American Art Association-Anderson Galleries, 1937. https://archive.org/details/royalrobesstateg00amer/page/n3/mode/2up.

A 1937 Auction of Queen Alexandra’s Clothing (Part I)

All the garments now in the collection of the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York that once belonged to Queen Alexandra (1844-1925), consort of King Edward VII of the United Kingdom (1841-1910), came from a landmark auction comprising seventy lots of her clothing and other effects. Intriguingly, this sale also took place in New York, at the American Art Association Anderson Galleries, Inc., located on 30 East 57th Street, in all probability because there were no laws at the time that prevented items of historical value from leaving their country of origin. At the time of the auction, Samuel Wilson Soden, Esq., a court furrier with a shop on Regent Street in London, owned the items, whose sale was conducted according to his instructions on May 5, 1937.1

Below, I have provided a colour image for each of the items that I have been able to find on the Met’s website, with a lot of guidance from Victoriana Magazine’s annotations in the auction catalogue itself.2 I have decided to focus on apparel only, such as gowns, coats, and mantles, because these have historic value or were connected to major events in Queen Alexandra’s life. Therefore, I have paid special attention to clothes from her trousseau (she married in 1863), as well as gowns she wore as a Princess of Wales and later as a Queen consort who was very much in the public eye.

The various lots that made their way into the Met’s collection either have “Gift of Miss Irene Lewisohn, 1937” or “Rogers Fund, 1937” in the credit line. The Royal Ontario Museum in Toronto has a small collection of gowns from the auction, all of which were donated by Colonel Flanagan, a collector.3 However, the rest appear to have mostly vanished without a trace—if you have a clue regarding their whereabouts, please leave a comment.

Identifying the pieces is hard work and requires a lot of guesswork, partly because the 1937 catalogue suffers from a paucity of photographs and incomplete or scanty descriptions (it omits names of designers). Descriptions from the catalogue are in italics (mine) and are numbered from 1 to 30. I have also highlighted items I could not find in yellow:

10. INDIAN WHITE AND GOLD BROCADE GOWN
Of damasse white silk brocaded with gold rosettes and borders; separate skirt in two pieces, the front panel with wide gold border at hem, the back forming a train. Coat-like bodice fastened in front, with long sleeves, high neck, lace jabot and collar. Worn by H. M. Queen Alexandra on the occasion of Queen Victoria’s Jubilee, when Her Majesty rode around London with Queen Victoria; woven especially for Her Majesty for that occasion and brought over by Viscount Hardinge; also worn at Ascot on Gold Cup Day.

10. Indian white and gold brocade gown [catalogue photo].

Where did it go?

16. GOLD EMBROIDERED WHITE SATIN GOWN
White satin embroidered in gold thread, gold sequins, and rhinestones, with an Empire design of laurel leaves in garlands and wreaths. In one piece, bodice with short bolero and short puffed sleeves trimmed with white tulle. With train. Worn by H. M. the Queen at the wedding of Grand Duchess Xenia, daughter of Czar Alexander III, at Peterhof Palace.

16. Gold embroidered white satin gown [catalogue photo].

I am fairly certain that the Royal Ontario Museum is the proud owner of the “gold embroidered white satin gown” these days, but I cannot prove this with a photograph, since its online database lists only a limited number of garments from its collection, none of which belonged to Queen Alexandra.

17. EMBROIDERED WHITE SILK COAT AND SCARLET BASHLIK
White faille silk coat, beaded and fringed; and scarlet bashlik with gold embroidery.

A white silk coat by Dieulefait & E. Bouclier that entered the Met’s collection in 1937 (see figure 1.1) closely matches the above description:

Figure 1.1. Dieulefait & E. Bouclier (French), Coat, late 19th-early 20th century, silk, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, C.I.37.44.5, source: The Met.

Figure 1.2 shows images of the gold-embroidered scarlet bashlik:

20. WHITE SILK AND LACE WRAP
Short mantle of white faille silk with insertions and vandyked borders of guipure lace; trimmed with silk cording at the neck. Part of H. M. Queen Alexandra’s trousseau.

Pictures of Queen Alexandra’s dainty and feminine-looking lace wrap can be seen in figure 1.3:

21. GOLD AND SILVER-EMBROIDERED BLUE TULLE GOWN
Light blue tulle embroidered in gold and silver beads with floral dies and broad bands at the top and hem; on blue satin foundation. Tight swathed bodice with square-cut neck and short sleeves; skirt gathered to the back with short train. Worn at King Edward’s Coronation, 1902.

Sounds lovely, doesn’t it? Blue must have been a pleasant change from Queen Alexandra’s usual colour choices at the time (i.e., black and purple, the colours of full- and half-mourning, respectively, which she favoured after the death of her son, Prince Albert Victor, in 1892). But where is it now? Unfortunately, the auction catalogue’s lack of a photograph adds to the challenge of finding the gown.

25. BLACK SEQUIN AND TULLE STATE GOWN
Embroidered with allover design and radiating stripes in sequins; black taffeta foundation, with pleated tulle flounces at hem. Separate bell-form skirt with train; three bodices, one with short sleeves of ball fringe, two with long sleeves and high necks, trimmed with ecru lace. Worn by H. M. the Queen for the State Opening of Parliament on several occasions; worn with the Garter Robe Orders, the Victoria and Albert, the Crown of India, the St. Catherine of Russia, and the Danish Royal Family Orders.

Unfortunately, this four-piece garment also seems to have disappeared and again, a photograph in the catalogue might have helped with its identification.

26. GOLD-TRIMMED BLACK WOOL COATEE
Sleeveless jacket of black wool trimmed with voltes and bands of gold braid. Part of H. M. Queen Alexandra’s trousseau.

The coatee in question was sold by Austin Auction Gallery in early 2021 (see figure 1.4). The auctioneer states that this piece was “purchased by Miss Gladys Emerson Cook (American, costume designer, active in New York City, 1899-1976) at the May 5, 1937 sale at the American Art Association Anderson Galleries in New York City, billed as an ‘unique assemblage of royal robes and state gowns, formerly belonging to H.M. Queen Alexandra, including toilettes worn at her coronation and from her trousseau.'”4 There is no doubt that this is the same coatee, as the auctioneer identifies it as lot 26 in the 1937 catalogue.

27. SCOTTISH TARTAN AND WHITE SATIN CRINOLINE BALL DRESS
Plaid satin panniers in the Royal Stuart tartan over a separate skirt of white satin ruffles outlined in red, with internal stiffening. Pointed bodice with pleated bertha trimmed with black lace, and short white tulle sleeves. With belt and separate collar. Worn at the Scottish Balls at Balmoral when H. M. the Queen first came to England.

27. Scottish tartan and white satin crinoline ball dress [catalogue photo].

The above dress, made by Madame Elise, a London dressmaking establishment, in 1863 or so, currently resides at the Royal Ontario Museum under the accession number 942.12.1.A-E. Madame Elise also created for Alexandra a tartan-printed evening gown that dates to about 1870 and is in the collection of the Fashion Museum, Bath.

29. MAUVE CHIFFON AND PURPLE SEQUIN GOWN
Black tulle embroidered all over with graduated purple sequins, mauve chiffon underdress, on a satin foundation; separate bell-shaped skirt with train, pointed bodice with square-cut neck and collar and short bell sleeves. Worn by H. M. Queen Alexandra during the Coronation year, 1902.

A gown in the Met’s collection database (figure 1.5) seems to answer to the above description:

Figure 1.5. Maker unknown (French), Evening dress, 1902, silk, sequins, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, C.I.37.44.2a, b, source: Pinterest.

30. EMBROIDERED BLACK VELVET RIDING COAT AND HAT
Coat with flared skirt and three-quarter puffed sleeves, high lace collar, jabot, and cuffs; embroidered in gold and appliqué silks with floral borders and mock pockets. Black velvet hat trimmed with pink and black ostrich plumes. (Lot.)

The eighteenth-century inspired riding ensemble described above now resides in the Met’s collection (see figure 1.6):

In Part II, I will cover lots 31 to 70 of the auction. Stay tuned!

Notes

1. American Art Association-Anderson Galleries, Inc., Royal Robes and State Gowns, Including Toilettes Worn at the Coronation and from the Trousseau of H. M. Queen Alexandra, Comprising Coats, Kashmir Shawls, Bags, Gloves and Embroidered Slippers, with Other Examples of the Richest Fashions of the Period from 1863 to 1907: Auction in New York, May 5, 1937 (New York: American Art Association-Anderson Galleries, 1937), https://archive.org/details/royalrobesstateg00amer/page/n3/mode/2up; Kate Strasdin, Inside the Royal Wardrobe: A Dress History of Queen Alexandra (London: Bloomsbury, 2017), chap. 9, Kindle.

2. “Victorian Clothing | Auctioning a Queen’s Wardrobe,” Victoriana Magazine, accessed January 13, 2024, http://www.victoriana.com/library/queen.html.

3. Strasdin, Inside the Royal Wardrobe, chap. 9.

4. “H.M. Queen Alexandra Gold Braid Wool Coatee – Jan 17, 2021 | Austin Auction Gallery in TX,” LiveAuctioneers, accessed January 5, 2024, https://www.liveauctioneers.com/item/95229522_hm-queen-alexandra-gold-braid-wool-coatee.

Bibliography

American Art Association-Anderson Galleries, Inc. Royal Robes and State Gowns, Including Toilettes Worn at the Coronation and from the Trousseau of H. M. Queen Alexandra, Comprising Coats, Kashmir Shawls, Bags, Gloves and Embroidered Slippers, with Other Examples of the Richest Fashions of the Period from 1863 to 1907: Auction in New York, May 5, 1937. New York: American Art Association-Anderson Galleries, 1937. https://archive.org/details/royalrobesstateg00amer/page/n3/mode/2up.

Strasdin, Kate. Inside the Royal Wardrobe: A Dress History of Queen Alexandra. London: Bloomsbury, 2017. Kindle.